James Campbell “Politics Editor”, or “Liberal Politics Editor”?

I am certain that “James Campbell” of the Herald Sun, will read this blog and any comments posted.

James, it is my personal opinion that you are a disgrace to your profession. Where is the balance in your constant monologue of blatant union bashing?

FACT: Victoria’s paramedics voted in favour for all current (and absolutely legal) industrial actions and the union executive did not (nor will they) take any action without approval of their paramedic membership.

Try changing the word “union” in your future comments and replace it with “paramedics”.

I doubt though, that you would, because even “Liberal inclined” members of the public would respond differently if your “union bashing”, became “paramedic bashing”. Tell me that I’m wrong!

The following is a complete reproduction of James Campbell’s latest effort at “unbiased” reporting, or is it? Or click here to see the original article in the Herald Sun.

Please make up your own minds and leave your comments below this blog.

Oh, and James (Campbell) please add your reply here too. It will not be suppressed!

Refusal of ambos union to face the ump is puzzling
SEPTEMBER 24, 2014 5:47PM

THE long pay dispute involving the state’s paramedics, which has been rumbling on for two years, took a turn for the worse last week with ambulance officers voting to expand indefinite industrial action.

The new bans, which begin tomorrow, are a grab bag of irritants designed to get under the skin of Ambulance Victoria management. Along with a refusal of ambos who live in rural areas to use their own cars “to travel to locations which are not their usual place of work” and a ban on acting team managers and senior team managers attending any meetings with external agencies or organisations, union members in management jobs won’t be taking part in any disciplinary and counselling matters.

There’s a lot more of this sort of stuff, none of which should cause anyone who might need an ambulance to lose sleep. Indeed, you can be assured union officials will be careful not to do anything that might put lives at risk.

If they were to do so, Ambulance Victoria would have the matter into Fair Work Australia for arbitration faster than you can dial 000. And that is the last thing the union wants.

With roughly a month until the Napthine Government goes into caretaker mode, the union seems content to run out the clock on the dispute, presumably in the hope that a victorious Labor Party will reward its members for all the good work they have done in getting Daniel Andrews elected.

To summarise the situation, the Government has offered a 6 per cent pay rise this year with 3 per cent next year and 3 per cent the year after that. As a sweetener it is also offering a $3000 signing bonus for accepting the deal.

But that’s not all. Unlike the police and nurses whose EBAs preclude their unions trying to get any more money during their life, the Government has agreed that if the ambos sign, they can go to Fair Work and argue their work is undervalued.

When negotiations for the new EBA began in 2012, AV had hopes of achieving productivity improvements, including expanded use of Ambulance Community Officers, changes to part-time paramedic entitlements as well as changes to meal allowances and what is called the “rolled-in rate”.

Over the course of the journey, however, those plans have been abandoned. The only two sticking points — aside from money — between the two sides are “union facilitation” and “rural relieving”.

Union facilitation is the present arrangement by which taxpayers and ambulance subscribers have to pay a paramedic 13 weeks’ pay a year to work at the union.

We also have to pay for 15 union delegates to attend six council meetings a year.

The union’s position is that it is non-negotiable — indeed, it would like to increase the number of paramedics released to attend to union business. The Government estimates that costs about $250,000 a year.

Ambulance Victoria’s position is that it is prepared to have the matter adjudicated by Fair Work.

More important than time off for union delegates, however, is the rural relieving issue.

AV is proposing that paramedics in rural areas might have to drive “about an hour” from their usual place of work to fill in gaps in rosters.

The idea is to create a pool of volunteers prepared to undertake this work but if there aren’t enough volunteers, then paramedics could be compelled to fill in — but only for a maximum of four weeks a year.

This being the public service, naturally they will be paid an allowance for being on the relieving roster even if they are not required to travel away from their usual place of work. They will not be required to stay away from home.

Again, AV’s position is it is prepared to allow Fair Work to arbitrate the matter, to which the union has said no way.

Interestingly, a similar system is already in place in Melbourne.

Perhaps it is unreasonable to expect people to have to drive an hour to work even for four weeks a year and we should all be happy to pay for non-working union officials.

In which case it is strange that the union is refusing to have the matter adjudicated by the workplace umpire.


About admin

In 2011 after more than 37 years I, like many paramedics since then, resigned from Ambulance Victoria. I am now a Tour Guide in the Northern Territory. I started the "Talkfest Forum for Australasian Paramedics" in 2009. It now has well over 1,000 members from all over Australia. This is fine for informal comments about all thing work related, but did nothing to inform the public about paramedics' concerns. This "FAIR-GO BLOG" was started to allow paramedics and others, to inform the general public about things that they are either concerned about or feel that the public would benefit from knowing. Paramedics in all States, have said that they cannot safely make any public comments in regard to their work or their management, for fear of being reprimanded or even dismissed. This is therefore a way for them to communicate with, and receive feedback from, the public. There is a very good reason why Paramedics have been independently voted as the most trusted profession in Australia, while politicians have constantly been near the bottom of that same list. Who should you listen to when it comes to your well being? Did I hear you say... "politicians"? While I administer this blog, I do not advocate, indorse or necessarily agree with any of the opinions and/or comments posted on the blog. Posts and comments are the sole responsibility of those persons making them. John
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to James Campbell “Politics Editor”, or “Liberal Politics Editor”?

  1. Marty says:

    Couldn’t agree more John. The man is either an exceedingly poor journalist (also quite possible) or bought and paid for in a similar fashion to the full page ads these clowns have been forking out $$$ for in an attempt to discredit ambos. If this bloke wants a shred of credibility he might consider speaking and actually listening to real ambos to get an idea of what’s actually happening instead of blindly parroting the biased and loosely constructed crap that Davis, et al insist on carrying on with….

  2. Undervalued Paramedic says:

    Desperate liars this State Government. If they can’t hide the truth, they’ll lie about it.

  3. Fred Nuckle says:

    This buffoon is so full of misinformation it is not funny. Isn’t it AV the one who refuses to go to Fair Work to negotiate? An EBA is meant to last 3 years, not 5 so the pay offer was less than the 2.5%. I am sure Campbell is on a healthy salary working 9-5 with NO lives relying on someones skill and experience at all hours 24/7. Napthine has just given himself a pay rise the near salary of a paramedics annual base rate so 8 paramedics could be employed on his salary.
    There must be a kick-back somewhere

  4. Steve Boyle says:

    Dear James you appear to be doing well with your audition as the Liberal political spin editor but should you ever wish to write anything that even remotely resembles the facts feel free to give me a call. Steve Boyle 0411 129 427 Paramedic for 33 years

    • Marty says:

      Don’t think he’s gonna lower himself enough to talk to us shit kickers Steve, I’d love to hear you educate him though

  5. John Collins says:


    No mention in your article about how puzzling it is to the public and the paramedics who respond to their emergencies that the Government REFUSES TO RELEASE RESPONSE TIME DATA!! You should be pressuring the Government in you articles to release them so independent analysts and the public can make their own judgement as to the crisis in ambulance at the moment.

  6. Paddy says:

    I recently become a little more informed about the ambulance debate. I find the issues are similar to those in healthcare generally. Problems occur and do not result in change, as speaking out is not tolerated. It is very notable that Labor has agree to the requests of the Union, only to be matched by the Liberals…publicly…just before an election. Steve McGhie tells me that the contract has not been signed! I suggest that the electorate vote for minor parties and independents to enable better transparency, accountability and management of conflict of interest – and I declare that I am a candidate for the Voice for the West party in the seat of Niddrie.

Comments are closed.